Sports Trading Cards & Toys with Men's Magazines

Back to the Past Collectibles

Date(s) 9/22/2024 - 10/5/2024

Bidding is online-only and will run from Sunday, September 22 to Saturday, October 5. Lots will start closing at 6 PM Eastern.

Highlights include McFarlane Toys New England Patriots Super Bowl Championship action figures, 1953-55 Topps & Bowman Baseball Cards, mid-80s Pee-Chee Hockey Cards, and much more! Join the Pop Culture Rewind for over 100 lots worth of sports collectibles! The superstar starting lineup includes sports action figures (from brand like McFarlane and Starting Lineup) and trading cards (from the 50s to today featuring the MLB, NHL, NBA, and NFL). They are backed up by posters, equipment, and other sports related treasures. Cheering these sports heroes on are a variety of men's magazines, trading cars, calendars, and other pin-ups. For local bidders, lots from this auction may be picked up and invoices can be paid starting at 12pm noon on the Monday following the auction's close. For everyone else, shipping costs will be assessed and invoices will start becoming available later that day. Pick-up is available Monday through Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM, at our shipping & receiving entrance.

Bidding Open

Online-Only Auction

Shipping Available

Auction Details Register to Bid

Bidding Notice:

All bidding for this auction will be conducted exclusively online through HiBid.com.

Show Search Bar

Quick Search

Single Page

Sort:

Show:

Showing 1 to 100 of 105 lots

Lot 1 |

Autographed Baseball + Photo Lot

Watch

High Bid: 170.00 USD

13 Bids

12h 34m

Lot 2 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

12h 35m

Lot 3 |

Starting Lineup Hockey Classic Doubles Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 35m

Lot 4 |

Vintage Chevrolet Club + GM Publication Lot

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 36m

Lot 5 |

1990 Baseball Card Sealed Box Packs Lot

Watch

High Bid: 50.00 USD

5 Bids

12h 36m

Lot 7 |

McFarlane Toys Hockey Figure Lot of (9)

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

4 Bids

12h 37m

Lot 8 |

Ship + Plane Photo Scrapbook/Compilations Lot (2)

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

12h 38m

Lot 9 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 38m

Lot 10 |

1980s-1990s Sport Trading Card Assorted Lot

Watch

High Bid: 45.00 USD

8 Bids

12h 39m

Lot 11 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (10)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 39m

Lot 12 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

12h 40m

Lot 12a |

Uncut 1993 Notre Dame Football Trading Card sheet

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 40m

Lot 13 |

Assorted Loose Starting Lineup MLB Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

12h 41m

Lot 14 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 41m

Lot 15 |

Topps Black & Gold Baseball Cards A-D Set Lot of 9

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 42m

Lot 16 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 42m

Lot 18 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

3 Bids

12h 43m

Lot 19 |

Universal Monsters -Crestwood House Books Lot (13)

Watch

High Bid: 120.00 USD

11 Bids

12h 44m

Lot 20 |

Uncut 1990's Racing Trading Card Lot of (2)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 44m

Lot 20a |

Tom Brady/Calvin Johnson Rookie Cards

Watch

High Bid: 50.00 USD

5 Bids

12h 45m

Lot 21 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Classic Doubles Figures

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 45m

Lot 22 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 46m

Lot 23 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (15)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 46m

Lot 24 |

Assorted Loose McFarlane NHL Toy Figure Lot (10)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 47m

Lot 24a |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 47m

Lot 25 |

1990 Score Baseball Sets & Traded Card Set Lot

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 48m

Lot 26 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 48m

Lot 27 |

Assorted Sports Souvenir + Paraphernalia

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 49m

Lot 28 |

Men's Interest Trading/Collector's Cards| Olivia

Watch

High Bid: 35.00 USD

4 Bids

12h 49m

Lot 29 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 50m

Lot 30 |

1980s-2000s Baseball Trading Card Assorted Lot

Watch

High Bid: 45.00 USD

5 Bids

12h 50m

Lot 31 |

Starting Lineup Stadium Stars Sealed Figures (7)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 51m

Lot 32 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 51m

Lot 33 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (10)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 52m

Lot 34 |

Assorted Sports Hat + Accessory Lot

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

12h 52m

Lot 35 |

1990-91 NBA Hoops Basketball Card Sealed Packs Lot

Watch

High Bid: 40.00 USD

4 Bids

12h 53m

Lot 36 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (16)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 53m

Lot 36a |

Tom Brady Madden NFL 18 Ultimate Team Series (2)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

12h 54m

Lot 37 |

McFarlane Toys Hockey Figure Lot of (8)

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

12h 54m

Lot 38 |

Assorted Loose McFarlane MLB Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 55m

Lot 40 |

1984 Topps Baseball Trading Card + Rookies/HOF Lot

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

3 Bids

12h 56m

Lot 40a |

1990s-2000s Football/Hockey/Basketball Card Lot

Watch

High Bid: 60.00 USD

6 Bids

12h 56m

Lot 41 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Classic Doubles Figures

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 57m

Lot 42 |

Assorted Sport Posters Lot

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

12h 57m

Lot 43 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 58m

Lot 44 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

12h 58m

Lot 45 |

1987-1990 Topps & Upper Deck Baseball Card Sets

Watch

High Bid: 35.00 USD

3 Bids

12h 59m

Lot 46 |

Starting Lineup Hockey Figure Lot of (16)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

12h 59m

Lot 47 |

McFarlane Toys Hockey Figure Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

2 Bids

13h

Lot 48 |

Starting Lineup Sport Variety Figure Lot of (26)

Watch

High Bid: 70.00 USD

6 Bids

13h

Lot 48a |

McFarlane Patriots Super Bowl Champions Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 40.00 USD

5 Bids

13h 1m

Lot 49 |

Vintage 60's/70's Art Poster Lot

Watch

High Bid: 110.00 USD

13 Bids

13h 1m

Lot 50 |

Vintage to Modern Sports Magazine Lot

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 2m

Lot 51 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Freeze Frame Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 2m

Lot 52 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (14)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 3m

Lot 53 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 3m

Lot 54 |

Dick Butkus VTG 1970 Sports Illustrated Poster (5)

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

3 Bids

13h 4m

Lot 55 |

1980s-1990s Baseball Trading Card Assorted Lot

Watch

High Bid: 45.00 USD

6 Bids

13h 4m

Lot 56 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (10)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 5m

Lot 57 |

McFarlane Toys Cooperstown Baseball Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

13h 5m

Lot 58 |

Starting Lineup MLB Sets + More Lot

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 6m

Lot 60 |

1983 Topps Baseball Trading Card Lot

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

2 Bids

13h 7m

Lot 60a |

1980s-2022 Baseball Card Lot w/ Keys

Watch

High Bid: 40.00 USD

5 Bids

13h 7m

Lot 60b |

Tom Brady Madden NFL 19 Gold Team Fantasy (2)

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

13h 8m

Lot 61 |

Baseball Book Lot + More

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 8m

Lot 62 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (9)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 9m

Lot 63 |

Starting Lineup Cooperstown Figure Lot of (16)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 9m

Lot 64 |

Assorted Adult/Erotic Literature Lot

Watch

High Bid: 45.00 USD

4 Bids

13h 10m

Lot 65 |

1986 O-Pee-Chee Hockey Trading Cards w/ Keys Lot

Watch

High Bid: 200.00 USD

18 Bids

13h 10m

Lot 66 |

NHL Hockey Assorted Merchandise Lot + More

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

3 Bids

13h 11m

Lot 67 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 11m

Lot 68 |

Starting Lineup Hockey Figure Lot of (15)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 12m

Lot 70 |

1985 Topps Baseball Trading Card w/ Keys Lot

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 13m

Lot 72 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (7)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 14m

Lot 72a |

McFarlane Baseball World Series Champions Figures

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 14m

Lot 73 |

Starting Lineup Cooperstown Figure Lot of (15)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 15m

Lot 74 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 15m

Lot 75 |

1980s-1990s Baseball Trading Card Assorted Lot

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

13h 16m

Lot 76 |

Starting Lineup Stadium Stars Sealed Figures (7)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 16m

Lot 77 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 17m

Lot 78 |

Starting Lineup Baseball's Greats Figure Lot of 8

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 17m

Lot 79 |

McFarlane Wayne Gretzky Oilers 12" Figure (3)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 18m

Lot 80 |

1990-1991 Hockey Card Box Packs

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

3 Bids

13h 18m

Lot 80a |

1986 Topps Baseball Card MEGA-Lot w/Keys

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 19m

Lot 82 |

McFarlane Toys Cooperstown Baseball Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 20m

Lot 83 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (15)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 20m

Lot 84 |

Vintage to Modern UFC Fighting Poster Lot of (15)

Watch

High Bid: 35.00 USD

4 Bids

13h 21m

Lot 84a |

Madden NFL 17 Ultimate Team Series (2)

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

13h 21m

Lot 85 |

1984 O-Pee-Chee Hockey Trading Cards w/ Keys Lot

Watch

High Bid: 170.00 USD

14 Bids

13h 22m

Lot 86 |

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 22m

Lot 87 |

Assorted Sports Magazine Lot

Watch

High Bid: 0.00 USD

0 Bids

13h 23m

Lot 88 |

Starting Lineup Cooperstown Figure Lot of (15)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 23m

Lot 89 |

McFarlane Toys Hockey Figure Lot of (5)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 24m

Lot 90 |

1980s-1990s Baseball Trading Card Assorted Lot

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

13h 24m

Lot 91 |

Wayne Gretzky Figure + Game Lot

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 25m

Lot 93 |

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (16)

Watch

High Bid: 25.00 USD

2 Bids

13h 26m

Lot 94 |

McFarlane Toys Hockey Figure Lot of (4)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 26m

Lot 95 |

1980s Baseball Traded Sets Card w/ Keys Lot

Watch

High Bid: 30.00 USD

3 Bids

13h 27m

Lot 96 |

Men Interest's Poster Lot (4)

Watch

High Bid: 20.00 USD

1 Bid

13h 27m

Lot 96a |

McFarlane Patriots Super Bowl Champions Figure Lot

Watch

High Bid: 35.00 USD

4 Bids

13h 28m

Sports Trading Cards & Toys with Men's Magazines | HiBid Auctions

Back to the Past Collectibles

Autographed Baseball + Photo Lot

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Starting Lineup Hockey Classic Doubles Figure Lot

Vintage Chevrolet Club + GM Publication Lot

1990 Baseball Card Sealed Box Packs Lot

McFarlane Toys Hockey Figure Lot of (9)

Ship + Plane Photo Scrapbook/Compilations Lot (2)

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

1980s-1990s Sport Trading Card Assorted Lot

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (10)

McFarlane Toys Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

Uncut 1993 Notre Dame Football Trading Card sheet

Assorted Loose Starting Lineup MLB Figure Lot

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Topps Black & Gold Baseball Cards A-D Set Lot of 9

Starting Lineup Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

McFarlane Toys Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

Universal Monsters -Crestwood House Books Lot (13)

Uncut 1990's Racing Trading Card Lot of (2)

Tom Brady/Calvin Johnson Rookie Cards

Starting Lineup Baseball Classic Doubles Figures

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (15)

Assorted Loose McFarlane NHL Toy Figure Lot (10)

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

1990 Score Baseball Sets & Traded Card Set Lot

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Assorted Sports Souvenir + Paraphernalia

Men's Interest Trading/Collector's Cards| Olivia

McFarlane Toys Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

1980s-2000s Baseball Trading Card Assorted Lot

Starting Lineup Stadium Stars Sealed Figures (7)

Starting Lineup Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (10)

Assorted Sports Hat + Accessory Lot

1990-91 NBA Hoops Basketball Card Sealed Packs Lot

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (16)

Tom Brady Madden NFL 18 Ultimate Team Series (2)

McFarlane Toys Hockey Figure Lot of (8)

Assorted Loose McFarlane MLB Figure Lot

1984 Topps Baseball Trading Card + Rookies/HOF Lot

1990s-2000s Football/Hockey/Basketball Card Lot

Starting Lineup Baseball Classic Doubles Figures

Assorted Sport Posters Lot

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

McFarlane Toys Baseball Cooperstown Figure Lot

1987-1990 Topps & Upper Deck Baseball Card Sets

Starting Lineup Hockey Figure Lot of (16)

McFarlane Toys Hockey Figure Lot of (5)

Starting Lineup Sport Variety Figure Lot of (26)

McFarlane Patriots Super Bowl Champions Figure Lot

Vintage 60's/70's Art Poster Lot

Vintage to Modern Sports Magazine Lot

Starting Lineup Baseball Freeze Frame Lot of (5)

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (14)

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

Dick Butkus VTG 1970 Sports Illustrated Poster (5)

1980s-1990s Baseball Trading Card Assorted Lot

Starting Lineup Baseball Figure Lot of (10)

McFarlane Toys Cooperstown Baseball Figure Lot

Starting Lineup MLB Sets + More Lot

1983 Topps Baseball Trading Card Lot

1980s-2022 Baseball Card Lot w/ Keys

Tom Brady Madden NFL 19 Gold Team Fantasy (2)

Baseball Book Lot + More

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (9)

Starting Lineup Cooperstown Figure Lot of (16)

Assorted Adult/Erotic Literature Lot

1986 O-Pee-Chee Hockey Trading Cards w/ Keys Lot

NHL Hockey Assorted Merchandise Lot + More

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (5)

Starting Lineup Hockey Figure Lot of (15)

1985 Topps Baseball Trading Card w/ Keys Lot

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (7)

McFarlane Baseball World Series Champions Figures

Starting Lineup Cooperstown Figure Lot of (15)

McFarlane Toys Baseball Figure Lot of (6)

1980s-1990s Baseball Trading Card Assorted Lot